Posts by user "barrymung" [Posts: 5 Total up-votes: 2 Pages: 1]

barrymung
2025-06-12T16:13:00
permalink
Post: 11899419
Ok, so...

Some have said the RAT appears to have been deployed. This would suggest a hydraulic/electrical failure on the plane.

A hydraulic/electrical failure could well make it impossible to retract the gear immediately.

But, what do flaps do in the event of a major hydraulic/electrical failure? Is there a default that they revert back to?

We can, I think, rule out engine failure, at least single engine failure because the rudder is still straight on in the
Video. You can also hear the engines..

Subjects: Engine Failure (All)  RAT (All)

barrymung
2025-06-12T16:17:00
permalink
Post: 11899426
Originally Posted by Kerosine
Given the sound which clearly mimics the RAT, images and collective tech knowledge, what could lead to this symmetric loss of thrust/lift at 200ft?

Fuel supply/quality issues?
Gear unable to be retracted and flaps retracted due to no hydraulic pressure? It would certainly explain the RAT being deployed and the loss of lift.

Subjects: Hydraulic Failure (All)  Hydraulic Pumps  RAT (All)  RAT (Deployment)

1 user liked this post.

barrymung
2025-06-12T16:22:00
permalink
Post: 11899436
Originally Posted by KSINGH
You are saying the RAT is deployed but we can rule out engine failure?

I thought this was meant to the *professional* pilot\x92s forum
Well, the certainly sound like they are working; failed engines sound different. No sign of smoke or damage either.

Conceivably, it could be a double engine failure but that's very unlikely.

Subjects: Dual Engine Failure  Engine Failure (All)  RAT (All)  RAT (Deployment)

barrymung
2025-06-12T16:25:00
permalink
Post: 11899439
The chances of a double engine failure on take off are like a billion to one, and I think are certified to a million to one occurrence.

As you say they still provide power and pressure even if not running

Subjects: Dual Engine Failure  Engine Failure (All)

1 user liked this post.

barrymung
2025-06-12T16:29:00
permalink
Post: 11899441
Ok, so...

Some have said the RAT appears to have been deployed. This would suggest a hydraulic/electrical failure on the plane.

A hydraulic/electrical failure could well make it impossible to retract the gear immediately.

But, what do flaps do in the event of a major hydraulic/electrical failure? Is there a default that they revert back to? I was under the impression the RAT can't power the flaps?

We can, I think, rule out engine failure, at least single engine failure because the rudder is still straight on in the
Video. You can also hear the engines..

Subjects: Engine Failure (All)  RAT (All)